Haydn Proctor Inn of Court

MV Black Box Bill Signed

Details

Category: General Announcements

Published on Friday, 22 May 2015 17:26

Written by Christopher Campbell

Hits: 21855

Last week, the governor signed into law a bill limiting access to Event Data Recorders, commonly referred to as a "black box" in a motor vehicle. It's not an entirely accurate name, because it only records the last few seconds of data about a vehicle before a collision.  The bill applies to data including the “speed of the motor vehicle or the direction in which the vehicle is traveling, or both; vehicle location data; vehicle steering performance; vehicle brake performance including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before a crash; driver's seatbelt status; and information concerning a crash in which the motor vehicle has been involved.”

In civil practice, the data is supposed to be obtained through the regular discovery process.

It's a little different for criminal practice: it creates a privacy interest in the data (but not any audio or video). For law enforcement to get takes a search warrant or consent, or just a Grand Jury subpoena if all they are looking for is location data.  Two things: Although the bill only names consent as an exception to the warrant requirement, I doubt the legislature intended to statutorily limit the exceptions the State can assert. But you never know. Similarly, the bill enumerates the penalty at up to $5000 for a person who violates. I also doubt the legislature intended to exclude the exclusionary rule from applying to violations. But again, you never know.

CLICK HERE to see the bill.

Enjoy the Summer!!

Details

Category: General Announcements

Published on Monday, 07 July 2014 12:38

Written by Administrator

Hits: 21354

Enjoy the summer!  We will see everyone again in the fall. 

Breakout Sessions - November 5, 2014

Details

Category: General Announcements

Published on Tuesday, 28 October 2014 19:48

Written by Administrator

Hits: 20781

Just a reminder that on Nov. 5, 2014 there will be the Break-Out Haydn Proctor Inn of Court meetings:

The Criminal Group will be meeting at Lomurro, Davidson, Eastman & Munoz in Freehold at 5:30, any questions, please give Jack Hazard a call.

The Civil and Family Groups will be meeting at the Monmouth County Courthouse, 3^rd Floor at 5pm.  If you are attending the Civil & Family Group meeting, could you please R.S.V.P. to Renee’ at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

Also, just a reminder that Dues are due. If you have any questions, please give Renee’ a call at 732-517-0900, or send her an email.

Bail Reform Committee Report

Details

Category: General Announcements

Published on Thursday, 20 March 2014 14:18

Written by Christopher Campbell

Hits: 22045

The NJ Supreme Court Joint Committee on Criminal Justice’s report containing recommendations for bail changes was released today:

Press Release: http://www.judiciary.state.nj.us/pressrel/2014/pr140320a.pdf

Full Report: http://www.judiciary.state.nj.us/pressrel/2014/FinalReport_3_20_2014.pdf

The recommendations include:

Judges relying on objective factors to assess the level of risk an individual defendant poses and then impose appropriate conditions of pretrial release.

Pretrial service officers to monitor compliance with nonmonetary conditions of release and supervise defendants who are released pretrial.

A system of preventative detention for judges to use.

A speedy trial statute with a definitive timeframe for indictment and trial.